EXT. ALLY IN BETWEEN TWO TALL BUILDINGS – DAY
MAY 31, 2005 - TUESDAY
The ally is empty of human interactivity. The
wind blows a few pieces of loose paper across the ground. Slowly,
we begin to look up in between the two buildings. We see that two
people dressed all in black are hanging from the bottom of a balcony.
At first glance you might think that this is a situation that Mulder
and Krycek have gotten themselves into. However as we get closer to
the subjects hanging, underneath the balcony, we see that it is not
Mulder and Krycek, but Dana Scully and Monica Reyes. It looks like
they’ve been hanging here, from their hands, for a long enough time.
I swear, Monica, the next
time you say you know how
to get out of a building without
being caught, we’re not doing
it. The Reyes Way does not save
the day. My strength is giving in,
my hands hurt, and seriously I think
when we actually have to fall down
five stories, we’re going to be hospitalized.
Monica looks down below them, as if she’s
waiting for something to happen. She sighs.
Dana, I told you to trust
me, didn’t I? I know what
Scully sarcastically chuckles. She’s not
happy about this current Monica Reyes situation.
Scully’s thoughts: I mean, Jesus, at least
if those men had caught us we may have a chance at living, but no-oooooo
Monica wanted to rush out the window and dangle five stories above
concrete. We’re going to die.
We’re not going to die.
Scully gives her a look.
Monica really, if you can
block reading my thoughts
I’d appreciate it. I have no
sense of privacy around you anymo-
Suddenly lets out a quiet scream as she
struggles to keep her grasp on the wooden plank of the balcony she
is holding on to.
Ow! Damn splinter.
If you don’t shut up
they’re going to find us.
What you can hear their
No. They’ll hear where
we are and come out here
and eliminate us as a problem.
It’s not our fault they’re
dealing with the mob and
making people disappear.
I know, but I don’t think
we want them to catch us.
We’re much better off out here.
Yeah, until we fall and die.
(beat) You know, John better
find some kind of psychic
ability in himself and get his
butt out here to save us.
There’s no need for that.
How do you figure?
The building across the way,
that’s an orphanage.
So? What? Are kids
going to come to our rescue?
Big teddy bear…
Scully cocks an eyebrow. What the hell
does that mean?
Monica reaches out and grabs Scully’s arm
with one hand and tugs at it.
Drop now or die later!
Monica gives one big tug on Scully’s arm
to release her grip on the balcony plank. The two of them fall five
stories down and land on top of a large teddy bear stuffed animal
that has been put into a garbage truck. The truck is moving, driving
out of the ally. Good thing Mulder and Brad gave this teddy bear to
the orphanage, otherwise the FBI would be picking up Dana and Monica’s
remains with a spatula. Guess everything does happen for a reason
Scully sits up, rubbing her upper right arm.
You all right?
I hit my arm on the
side of the truck on
the way down.
Scully turns so Monica can see where on
her arm it hurts. The black jacket sleeve is torn and Monica can see
that Scully is bleeding.
You’re bleeding. We
need to get you to a
Scully twists around herself to better
view her arm. Sure enough, she’s bleeding. Her eyes go wide.
It tore through two layers
of clothing! This is my
Dana, you shouldn’t hold
such attachment for
It’s only a jacket, I’m sure
John will buy you a new one.
You’re sure, or you know he will?
Monica gives Scully a sly smile. She looks
in the direction of where the driver is.
At the next stop light
I’m going to hop out and
ask the driver to take us
to the nearest hospital.
Yeah, I’ll do that too.
It smells in here.
That would be leftover
food from the orphanage.
Scully’s nose wrinkles up with disgust.
Those poor kids…
I should consider adopting
someday, save the taste buds
of a child.
Since I made the decision to not activate
that chip in my neck so I could one day conceive a child…
She’s bitter at herself for that decision. She
so badly wishes to have a family of her own one day. When she’s ready.
Monica heard her thoughts.
She’s trying to pretend that she hadn’t
read Scully’s mind.
Those children have no family.
I think I’d make a good mother,
and if I can help a life by
giving a child stability and love, why not?
You and John
will be great parents one day.
Monica smiles. A smile that suggests that
she knows something more than she’s saying.
The garbage truck comes to a stop. Monica and
Scully quickly climb out of the back and approach the driver side.
Scully pulls out her FBI credentials. Monica knocks on the window,
and Scully holds her credentials up for the driver to see. The driver
rolls down his window.
(a bit nervous)
Have I done something wrong?
Monica’s eyes widen as she feels and knows
that this man really, really enjoys his trips to the orphanage. She
says nothing, knowing that now she wants to find proof that this man
is a pedophile, which her gift is telling her that he is.
No, you’ve done nothing wrong.
We sort of fell into the back
of your truck and need to have
you drop us off at the nearest
Sure, hop on in, that’s
not a problem for me.
Scully puts her credentials away and she
and Monica walk in front of the garbage truck to get in on the passenger
He’s a pedophile.
Scully looks at her with a bit of disbelief,
only she knows better because she is aware of Monica’s ability, and
she knows that Monica would not make something up like this.
Look, we can forget about
the mob goons and focus on
this guy. The mob always
gets away anyway, and if we
go back to the-
- Monica, we were assigned
the mob case. We need to let
A.D. Follmer know we found
nothing that suggests that
these guys were using a portal
to quickly move from one side
of D.C. to another in a matter
Scully wants to remain focused on the case
Scully opens the passenger door and climbs up
into the truck, sitting in the middle. She smiles at the driver, and
he smiles back in a way that makes her uncomfortable, an uneasiness
that makes her feel like a vulnerable child. Monica sits next to her
and shuts the door.
The light goes green and the driver starts driving
to the nearest hospital.
Scully notices a picture of a few kids on the
Cute kids. Are they yours?
The little girl wearing
the ballet tutu is my daughter.
The others are some of her friends.
Monica elbows Scully on her wounded arm.
Scully flinches and quickly places her other hand on the wound. That
After a few minutes the driver stops in front
of the hospital entrance. Monica gets out of the truck.
Could we have your name, sir,
so that the Bureau can let
your supervisor know that
your time is accounted for?
Thank you for the ride,
Scully hands him one of her FBI business
If your supervisor has
any questions about you
running late on your
schedule, have him call
my office and I’ll vouch for you.
You have a fine day, Agent Scully.
He winks at her and smiles. Scully gives
him an uncomfortable smile back.
Scully gets out of the truck and it drives away.
She reaches into her jacket and pulls out her cell phone. She dials.
Why are you calling John?
Scully gives her a look that explains it
all: to tell him to look into Michael Barker.
I think we should get you
looked at, you don’t want
to get Tetanus.
As Scully waits for Doggett to answer his
phone, she and Monica walk into the hospital.
INT. DOGGETT / REYES OFFICE – X-FILES DIVISION
Doggett and Mulder are sitting alone in the
office, looking over information on the mob goons that Monica and
Dana are out in the field investigating. It’s obvious to us that Doggett
is not happy with having to sit in the office instead of being out
in the field with Monica and Dana. They’re both – in his mind – fresh
out of the FBI Training Academy and he feels he and Mulder should
have been assigned to do the search-but-no-touch investigation that
their warrant allowed them. However, Brad felt that it was important
to let the two of them work together to regain their confidence so
John bit his tongue and let the boss run things.
I sure hope that Agents
Scully and Reyes find
something. Despite what
the evidence says about
these guys being at the
scene of the crime at the time
of death, them showing up
across town at the same time
of death that the M.E. predicted,
with over a dozen witnesses,
does nothing to help us obtain
an arrest warrant for the murders.
I can’t believe that Brad
assigned them to that type
of work in the field.
With Monica and her newfound
abilities, I’m sure if these
men were to return, she’d know
way ahead of time.
Mulder smiles, having full confidence in
Monica’s psychic ability (which John continues to try to ignore is
Doggett’s cell phone rings. He picks it up and
sees that it is Scully. He answers.
Dana? Are you guys ok?
I got one hell of a gash
in my right arm, and a
few splinters in my
fingers, but other than
that I’m fine.
What? How’d that happen?
Fly and his goons showed
up and heard Mon’ and I.
We had to hang off a balcony
so not to get found.
Did they have you before that?
Did they gash your arm?
No, the garbage truck did.
I’ll explain later. I need
you to look into something
for Mon’ and I.
Ow! Shit that hurt!
John’s eyes go wide, thinking that maybe
Scully is trying to signal to him that she and Monica are in danger
with the mob goons. He stands up unknowingly.
Sorry John, I’m
not talking to you.
Doctor’s doing stitches.
Are you and Monica in any
danger? If you can’t say
anything that suggests
that I just asked you that, don’t
say anything at all.
Scully starts laughing at the other end
of the phone. He hears her cover the mouth piece of her cell phone
and speak to Monica: “John thinks that we’re in danger, Mon’.” Doggett
lets out a sigh of relief, if she’s saying that out-loud, they are
not in any trouble.
We’re all right, John.
So what do you need me to
A man named Michael Barker.
Doggett jots the name down on a pad of
Michael Barker… sounds familiar.
In the background of Scully’s phone, Doggett
hears Monica gasp.
John… Mon’ needs to speak with you.
Michael Barker. Robert Harvey.
See the connection?
Doggett tenses up upon hearing the name
Yeah… he was a suspect in
Luke’s case. What does
this Barker have to…
His words trail off as he remembers that
the name Michael Barker came up a few times in Monica’s interrogations
of Harvey back in 1993. Barker was Harvey’s alibi. The man who confirmed
that he and Harvey were nowhere near Long Island on the day Luke disappeared.
Barker, he’s a pedophile, John.
I saw it in his soul. He drives
a garbage truck that makes stops
at children’s orphanages. We need
to get him off the street.
Doggett is quiet for a beat.
What if… what if looking
into this guy leads us to
a new lead in Luke’s case.
Doggett chokes back tears as he thinks
about his son.
Monica hesitates to answer him, knowing very
well where checking into this case could lead them. She also knows
that Barker did not hurt Luke. Barker prefers little girls.
John, why don’t you check
up on him. If I remember
correctly, he is a registered
sexual predator. If he’s breaking
the terms of his release by
being near those kids at the
orphanage, we may be able to
investigate him more and convict
him of child rape again.
Sure. Mulder and I will look into
it. (beat) Is Dana going to be all right?
Doggett asks this with heartfelt concern.
It worries him that he is not with Dana now that she’s been hurt.
Doctor gave her a tetnus
shot and stitched her up.
Other than a scab and some
bruising she’ll be all right.
Doggett can almost feel Monica’s warm smile
through the phone.
You two get back here
as soon as you can. And
be careful, we haven’t seen
Krycek all day. Mulder thinks
that he’s up to something.
Ok. See you later.
Monica hangs up Scully’s phone.
Doggett places his phone down on his desk, he
looks at Mulder.
Looks like Dana and Monica
have assigned us a little
Off of Mulder’s intrigued look…
EXT. INTERROGATION ROOM – 5:30 P.M.
Doggett and Mulder are walking down the hallway
at the Washington D.C. Police Department. A few hours ago, they were
checking up on Michael Barker, and discovered that he has been violating
the terms of his parole.
So this guy may know more about
your son’s disappearance and murder?
He was the alibi for our main suspect.
After he cleared Harvey’s name, the case
went cold. Nothing new has ever come up.
No new leads, nothing. That’s the one thing
that bothers me most about the case, that
Harvey called in the location of my son’s
body, which was found in the middle of nowhere.
He gave no explanation on how or why he was
out in that field, so Monica saw that as enough
to name him as our suspect. Only his alibi…
Michael Barker claims they were far from Long
Island the day Luke was kidnapped.
Mulder and Doggett stop walking once inside
the Observation Room. They look through the window at Barker. He’s
sitting at a table, facing the two-way mirror.
Are you ready to go in there?
Doggett nods his head.
Let’s do this.
They open the door and enter the Interrogation
Room. Mulder takes a seat across the table from Barker, John stands
behind him in the corner in the room, eyeing Barker with intensity.
I’m agent Mulder and this is agent
Doggett. Have you been informed of
the reasons you were brought here today?
Yes, violation of my parole.
Barker looks at Doggett, recognizing his
Your parole officer informed us that
you’ve been read your rights, and have
signed the paperwork affirming this. In
which case I’d like to remind you before
I get started that you are allowed counsel
if you so desire. (beat) You can stop
questioning at any time if you wish to receive counsel.
That won’t be necessary. I’ve
got nothing to hide.
Photographs of young girls were found
inside the garbage truck you drive.
You told one of our agents that one girl
was your daughter. Though, looking at your
file, it says that you have no children.
Would you mind explaining to us why
you said that?
I lied. Thought they were on to
me. I didn’t want to get caught.
Doggett steps forward.
Caught doing what? Hurting little girls?
Barker looks John in the eye, a smirk forms
on his face.
Checking out the orphanage to see if
any little girl is to my liking. Feels
like forever since I’ve felt one of their
little bodies squirm below mine.
This remark furrows itself through John’s
flesh, angering him.
Who are the girls in the pictures?
C’mon, you’re FBI. You tell me.
All we’re trying to find out here,
Mr. Barker, is if you’ve raped any
other girls since you’ve been out on parole.
Barker takes a deep breath and sighs.
Look, I told you. All I did was take
a look, you can’t convict me of child
molestation if I haven’t yet committed a
crime (beat) Look, I’ll go back to that
frickin’ halfway house, and stay away if
that’s what you want me to do.
Doggett and Mulder share a look.
Barker looks in John’s direction.
What about him?
What’s it been now, twelve years
since the disappearance of a little
boy from Long Island, New York?
Oh, ok, Doggett. That’s where I know
your name from. You all thought Bob
took your son, right?
That’s correct, and because of your
statement that placed Harvey with you
in Salt Lake City on the day of disappearance,
the case remains unsolved. (beat) Right now,
you’re the only lead we’ve got.
I got paid to lie for him.
Paid by whom?
Can’t say I remember who, it’s been
so damn long. Harvey would know, he
did business with the guy.
And where can we find Harvey?
Last I heard, he moved his tight ass
down to New Orleans.
Doggett gives Mulder a look. Mulder stands
up to exit the room to go look into Harvey’s location. The door closes.
So you gonna let me go? I’m sure
my P.O. wants to bite my head off.
Doggett sits down across the table from
him. He pushes paper and pen toward him.
I need you to write out your
official statement that you were
paid to lie for Harvey back in ’93.
Not a problem. It’s not like they’re
still paying me to keep my mouth shut today.
Barker picks up the pen and starts writing
down his statement on paper, admitting that he is not a valid alibi
for Robert Harvey on the day of Luke’s disappearance.
INT. FBI FORENSIC LAB – 6:15 P.M.
Upon returning to the FBI after patching Scully
up at the hospital, Brad assigned Scully and Monica to searching Barker’s
garbage truck for any forensic evidence that he’s recently committed
crimes against young girls.
Monica is in the back of the truck, sifting
through garbage, and Scully is up front.
You know Dana, now I wish I had hurt
myself, that way I wouldn’t be the one
going through all this… eww! Ok, gross. Dead rat.
Doctor said I shouldn’t do that kind
of work. I don’t want anything to infect
Scully notices the seams to the driver’s
seat have been tampered with. She picks up a camera and takes a picture
of the seams before pulling out her pocket knife and cutting the seat
open. She pushes her hand through and pulls out a wad of photographs,
bound together with rubber bands. She snaps a photograph, then unbinds
The first photograph makes her have to hold
back vomit. Scully covers her mouth and closes her eyes to re-prepare
herself to see an image of a girl having an erected penis shoved down
Scully can feel the tough skin of the man’s
penis in her own throat, drops of pre-cum sliding down her throat.
She can’t breathe. Scully gasps for air and drops the photographs
to the floor. She grasps onto her stomach in agony, as if she is the
one taking the weight of an adult male on a child’s body. She violently
throws up on the ground by the passenger seat. In her head she hears
the sound of a man’s voice: “There, there, Dana… don’t be sick. I
love you, that’s why I’m doing this with you. There’s nothing bad
about being in love…”
Scully rolls onto her back on the seat and lets
out a soft cry. She covers her mouth to keep Monica from hearing her,
but she’s too late. Monica steps up into the front of the truck, and
sees Scully lying down, in tears. Monica can smell that Scully’s thrown
up. Monica looks down, and sees the pictures scattered all over the
Monica doesn’t touch her, knowing it will
startle her, and make the situation worse. Scully takes a deep breath,
she sits up, wiping tears from her eyes.
Shit. (beat) Mon’, I’m sorry, I didn’t
Scully looks at Monica with a worried tear-stained
That was like a flashback. What kind
of person experiences flashbacks of child rape when…
Scully closes her eyes to keep her next thought
from completely entering her mind.
Did you remember something that
happened to you?
Scully looks at Monica with lost eyes.
No… at least I don’t think so…
(beat) Um… I found pictures he
kept here inside his seat.
Scully bends over to pick up the photographs,
making sure not to look directly at them. Something catches her eye.
She blinks to make sure it’s not an illusion. She reaches down and
picks up a piece of fabric cut out in the shape of a heart.
Oh my God…
SMASH CUT TO:
INT. INTERROGATON ROOM – 7:20 P.M.
You tell me what you know about that
fabric heart I found inside your truck.
Scully is standing, both hands on the table
in front of her. She angrily leans toward Barker who is across from
her. He’s smiling.
So you found my heart. Actually, not
my heart really, I’m continuing the work
of a friend of mine. I think that agent
Mulder was a friend of his, well… until he
backstabbed him and placed a bullet in his head.
Scully’s stomach twists and turns.
Yeah, John, called me back in ’96 when
I was living in Boston. He said the feds
were after him, and that they’d probably
kill him when they found him.
INT. OBSERVATION ROOM – CONTINUOUS
Monica and Brad watch on, not completely understanding
what is going on. They watch Scully through the glass, her voice is
slightly muffled to them.
You worked with John Lee Roche?
No, I befriended him via mail while he
was locked away. I admired what a legend
he had become. His manner was so cool, so
calm, so friendly. He could have his way with
so many little girls. (beat) He told me that
the FBI had found his last three hearts. I read
that one of those three remains unsolved.
And you say you’re continuing his work.
(beat) What can you tell me about Roche’s
last heart, and the heart I found in your truck?
You mean you want to know the name
and whereabouts of John’s last victim,
He told you that information?
I can say “yes”, but would you really
trust the word of a pedophile?
Barker mimics a phrase that Roche said
to Mulder so many years ago. He eyes Scully, he can see that it bothers
her being alone in the room with him. He smirks.
You look like a frightened little girl.
Agent Scully, do you know what that
does to a man like me?
Barker pushes back in his seat to reveal
his emerging hard-on. Scully does her best not to show any reaction
I hate to disappoint you, Michael,
but I’m nowhere near the age that you prefer.
Don’t matter, I see that frightened little
girl, hiding inside you.
Scully fights back tears and bites her
lower lip. She stares blankly at Barker, unsure how to proceed in
The door to the room opens, and Brad steps in.
Agent Scully, a word please.
Scully gives Barker a look, then exits
the room with Brad. They shut the door behind them.
You’re referring to a case that neither
myself nor agent Reyes is familiar with.
Would you mind allowing us in the loop?
Monica steps out of the Observation Room
to join them. Scully takes a deep breath.
This man may know information about an
unsolved murder case that Mulder was
brought onto back in 1990. The case re-emerged
in ’96 and we discovered that Roche had
killed more than he initially stated. (beat)
The man I speak of, John Lee Roche, was a
serial child rapist and killer. After he killed
his victims he cut out heart-shaped pieces
of fabric from their clothing, he kept them as trophies.
That explains how finding the heart
in Barker’s truck lead to this interrogation.
Mulder shot and killed Roche back in ‘96
after he kidnapped a girl. Roche led Mulder
to believe that his final heart, the one
left unsolved, was Mulder’s sister, Samantha.
Do you believe Barker could help us
find the identity of Roche’s last victim?
I think it’s a possibility.
Do you believe it is Samantha?
No. Roche only used Sam’s disappearance to
manipulate Mulder, make him vulnerable. (beat)
I also do not believe that Barker kills the
girls he’s hurt, murder doesn’t fit with the
M.O. determined by our profilers. I believe
that he cuts out hearts in the same manner
as Roche in order to make himself feel as great
as he believes Roche was.
The three of them pause their conversation
when they hear erotic moaning coming from inside the Interrogation
Room. Brad watches Scully’s reaction, she wraps her arms protectively
around her waist.
I think it may be a good idea to call
Mulder in to help with this case. Mulder
was the profiler on Roche’s case in 1990,
I think he’d be best to deal with Barker’s
connection. Nobody else knows this case
as well as agent Mulder.
He and agent Doggett are down
in New Orleans checking up on
a lead in Luke’s case. They’re
going to question Bob Harvey
At this moment, Robert Comer passes them
in the hallway, he gives a slight nod to Monica and continues on his
way. He doesn’t stop to talk since it looks like they’re busy working
a case. He couldn’t help but overhear “New Orleans” and “Bob Harvey”
in Brad’s sentence.
The conversation continues on as he walks away.
You can call him up and send
either myself or agent Reyes
down to work with John.
Which case do you want to work on?
Scully bites her lower lip – most everything
about this Roche-Barker case is bothering her. She feels her stomach
turn as more moaning is heard coming from the Interrogation Room.
She knows that Barker is imagining himself with her, only envisioning
her as a little girl. That thought makes her sick to her stomach.
I know you said you worked this Roche
thing before, but I’m going to send you
and Monica down to New Orleans to look
into this Luke thing. I’ll call Mulder
and John up here to deal with Barker.
I think I may be more useful working
with Mulder up here since we both
were involved in the ’96 investigation
I don’t want you dealing with Barker,
agent Scully, not when we’re all hearing
him out here, knowing what he said to you
when you were alone with him. I can see
he makes you uncomfortable.
Scully says nothing. She can’t argue against
I’ll call John and tell him the
situation. I know he’s not going
to be happy to be taken off his
son’s case so I’ll deal with him.
Brad pulls out his cell phone and walks
away from them.
Christ, how obvious am I being about
how much this bothers me? What is it about those photographs I found that has struck a nerve with me? Is it possible that I am a victim of a pedophile and have no memory of the assault?
Monica looks at Scully, having heard her thoughts.
Dana, are you all right?
I know I’d be pretty shaken up
if Barker had said those things to me.
Monica gently places her hand on Scully’s
shoulder. Scully steps away from her, ending the physical contact.
I’m fine. (beat) We should go pack
up and head down to New Orleans. I’ll
call John before we leave to see if they’ve
already checked into a hotel, and if they can
have the keys held at the desk for us.
That way we can use their rooms and
save the Bureau some money.
Scully walks away.
Monica steps back inside the Observation Room,
and sees that Barker is done self-pleasuring. She watches him, trying
to concentrate on his thoughts, but she hears nothing. She sighs.
Hopefully by the end of each of these cases something good will result
either solving Luke’s case, or solving the unsolved Roche case.
EXT. DOWNTOWN BAR – 9:00 P.M.
Robert Comer leans against a cold, wet brick
wall of a crummy bar in downtown D.C. A light rain shower falls down
onto him, splatting on his black leather jacket. Comer pulls out a
pack of Morley cigarettes and puts one in his mouth. He covers his
hand over his lighter as he lights the cigarette, to keep the rain
from falling on it.
He takes in the nicotine, calming himself as
he waits nervously in the questionable side street. The street light
flickers, providing little light to see well.
Approaching footsteps catch his attention. He’s
heard these footsteps many times before. He straightens up as a man
rounds the corner of the building.
The man steps out of the darkness and into
the flickering, dim light to reveal himself as Nicholas Rigali – a
New York mobster with a mean look.
I thought you wanted out, Bob.
(beat) What changed your mind?
The FBI is going down to New
Orleans to question Bob Harvey
Comer takes a drag off of his cigarette.
Something about Luke Doggett.
Rigali smirks at him, remembering very
well the case of the missing police officer’s son.
Don’t act like you’re clueless, FBI.
(beat) You really think I don’t know
that you and Monica Reyes got close
in New Orleans? (beat) When I ask the
FBI for help, I always have someone on
them. (beat) Especially you, UC. So what now?
You and the FBI gone and set me up?
Hey, I’m not up to anything. This isn’t
some sting op to get your ass behind
bars. (beat) I’m just doing as you asked
and protecting your ass, letting you know
the FBI will be questioning Harvey tomorrow.
(beat) You might want to give him a heads up.
You should know that this questioning could
lead them straight to you.
Rigali can’t help but smile at Comer’s
willingness to cooperate in this.
I will. (beat) What made you come around?
Comer doesn’t give him an answer. He takes
another drag off his cigarette.
Could it be because of Monica Reyes?
I hear she’s back.
Comer looks at him.
What do you know about it?
Did you have something to
do with her disappearance last year?
Rigali smirks, liking the fact that Comer
thinks he’s the one responsible for Monica’s mysterious disappearance
last year. Though Rigali had nothing to do with that, it gives him
more fuel against Comer. Allows him the ability to control him even
A few years ago you stopped
doing as I asked.
She left New Orleans.
I want you to do it again.
Comer glares at Rigali.
To taunt someone who could
help us achieve what we want.
You mean taunt Brad Follmer.
Comer shakes his head. He can’t do this,
No. I’m not doing it anymore.
You can’t ask me to betray her
like that again.
Then I’ll find other ways to proceed.
Rigali looks at him with a threatening
look. Comer glares at him, hating him.
Fine. (beat) But not right
away. Give me some time.
That’s more like it.
Comer tosses his cigarette butt to the
(after a beat)
What time will they question
Sometime in the morning.
That’s all I know.
Comer makes his way out of the dark side
street, ending the conversation before anyone can see them talking
EXT. HOTEL – 11:43 P.M.
A yellow taxi cab pulls up outside of a tall
hotel building in downtown New Orleans. Scully and Monica get out
of the cab. Scully pays the driver as Monica retrieves their bags
from the trunk.
They walk into the hotel and use their FBI credentials
to obtain the keys to the rooms that Mulder and Doggett were staying
in. They head to the elevator.
I’m in 813.
What time did John say he and
Mulder were supposed to be at
Harvey’s to speak with him?
Eight in the morning.
Monica hits floors 6 and 8. The elevator
starts moving up.
Let’s meet downstairs for breakfast
at 6:30, then we’ll head out to find
Harvey’s home. I used to live down here
so there shouldn’t be a problem finding the place.
Sounds good to me.
We should stop by the field office
here in New Orleans, let them know
that we’re here. I’m sure Brad already
called them. It’s good to check in anyway.
The elevator stops on floor 6, Scully exits.
The elevator doors close and Scully makes
her way down the hallway to room 675. She uses her card key to open
the door, and is surprised to see John Doggett sitting in a chair
at a table. He’s still in his work clothes, with his sleeves rolled
up. He’s going over paperwork. He hasn’t noticed her enter.
Her eyebrow is raised considerably. Doggett
looks in her direction. He smiles and stands up to greet her.
You and Mon’ have a good flight down?
He wraps his arms around her, hugging her.
She hugs him back. She’s glad to see him, but she still wonders why
he’s not up in D.C. with Mulder to work on the Barker case.
You’re supposed to be with Mulder
in D.C., working on the Barker case.
Why are you still here?
Brad doesn’t think that I can work
this case without letting my personal
feelings get in the way. He’s wrong.
Doggett’s tone tells her that he’s already
let his personal connection to the case get in the way. Her heart
aches for him.
I got back here an hour ago from
taking Mulder to the airport.
Scully sighs, and walks further into the
(sensitive to his feelings)
John, you know Brad is not going
to be happy about this. You’re
disobeying orders from your direct superior.
Doesn’t matter, up in New York, they
tried to keep me out of the case. I was
with the NYPD, they were feds, and the
case became their jurisdiction and they
still didn’t succeed.
Doggett sees worry and concern all over
Look, I can handle myself with this
case. It’s following up on a lead, an
old suspect. I just… I need to be here
to look in this man’s eyes to know if
he’s lying or not. I spoke with Barker
earlier and he made a written statement
that he was paid to lie about Harvey’s
whereabouts on the day of Luke’s disappearance.
If this bastard is the one who took him,
raped him, and murdered him. I’m going to be
here to make the arrest.
You could get suspended for not
following orders, John.
And I don’t believe Brad would
do that to me.
Scully sighs, perhaps giving up too easily.
She’s worried for John, his heart is in the right place, but it is
possible that he can’t handle this case and may do something to compromise
the situation. She can sense that John has his mind made up, and that
there’s no changing it. She opens up her travel bag and retrieves
I’m going to get washed up and
changed. I want to be able to sleep
when I’m done. Could you please gather
all the paperwork and be ready for the
night by the time I get out of the bathroom?
Doggett nods his head. He knows that she’s
had a rough day. Brad informed him about her reactions to Barker earlier,
and then there was the mob job, and falling into a garbage truck and
having to get a Tetanus shot and stitches. It’s been a long day for
both of them.
He hears the shower turn on.
Doggett goes to the table and puts the paperwork
back in their file folders. He’ll continue going over the old files
before breakfast tomorrow morning. Even though he knows his son’s
case inside and out, he wants to make sure that he’s reviewed the
information again before he speaks to Harvey. He can’t let anything
slip his mind.
In three months it will be twelve years since
Luke was murdered. That’s too long for a case to remain unsolved.
He owes it to Luke to put the man who killed him behind bars. He owes
it to himself and to Barbara as well.
Barbara… he hasn’t yet called her to let her
know that he’s following up on a strong lead. He should do that sometime
soon. He knows that she doesn’t like it when he just shows up or calls
out of the blue with nothing more to offer except that he’s “checking
up on something”. The last time they spoke to one another about Luke,
she told him not to come bringing it up again unless it was the real
thing. What she meant by that was for the killer to have been arrested
and it proven that he in fact killed their son.
He saw her last July… almost a year ago. That
was back when he thought Dana and Monica had died in a car accident.
He didn’t know who else to turn to so he turned to her. He only spoke
with her that once about Dana and Monica being dead. He wonders now
if anyone had informed her that they were alive and as well as can
be expected considering the circumstances. He wonders if Barbara is
still seeing that lawyer friend of Martin’s, Jack. Maybe one day when
things are less tense between them (about Luke), he and Dana could
meet up with them for lunch. It’d be nice if he’d be able to keep
a friendship with Barbara after all they’ve been through. Perhaps
finally solving Luke’s case could make that easier.
He looks toward the bathroom door and smiles.
He’s finally got someone that makes him happy.
Doggett goes to his travel bag, he unbuttons
his shirt and takes it off. He removes his slacks and slips into gray
sweatpants and slips on his gray Marines t-shirt. He looks at Scully’s
travel bag and wonders if he should get her a separate room, so that
he’s not breaking any other Bureau rules and regulations tonight –
other than ignoring the orders of his direct superior.
He hears that the shower turned off.
He walks to the bathroom door and knocks. He
scratches the back of his neck.
Dana? Did you want me to get
a room of my own?
Scully steps out of the bathroom, her hair
is wet and she smells like spring flowers. She’s already in her purple
satin pajamas. She’s drying her hair with a towel. She’s beautiful
even without her hair done up and no makeup on her face. Doggett smiles.
That’s all right. Honestly, I really
need to be with you tonight. After the
day I’ve had, I don’t want to be alone.
Scully doesn’t elaborate on why she feels
this way. She doesn’t want to talk about the child rape flashback
she had earlier, that she suspects may have happened to her in her
past, only she hadn’t remembered it until earlier that day. She doesn’t
want to bother John with her problems. She doesn’t want him to worry
more about her than he already does. She’ll cope with her problems
on her own, it’ll be easier that way.
Scully pulls down the blankets of the bed and
crawls in. She rests her back up against the headboard. She lets out
a sigh. She wishes she could curl up in a ball and never get out of
Do you need to talk?
Doggett sits next to her on the bed. He
hopes that this is the moment in which she decides to open up to him,
let him know what has been bothering her since she returned from the
Facility this past January. He also wonders if he’ll be sleeping in
bed next to her, or on the floor if she’s not comfortable being so
close to him at this time.
Scully sinks down into a lying position.
I’d rather sleep.
Nope, she’s not opening up to him tonight.
He’s disappointed. She’s been back for five months now and is still
choosing to deal with what has happened to her all on her own.
Is it all right if I stay
here in bed with you?
He feels odd asking her this question since
it isn’t the first time they’ve slept in the same bed together, but
since he doesn’t know how she’d react to this, he feels compelled
to ask. He doesn’t want a repeat of her shutting the door on him,
and crying like what happened on her birthday when he tried to kiss
her. In fact, they still have not kissed any more than pecks on the
cheek or quickly on the lips. She’s staying away from passion and
emotion with him, and he doesn’t know why.
I wouldn’t have it any other way.
(beat, joking) Plus I’m sure both
Brad and Mon’ will have it in for
you tomorrow, you’ll need a good night’s sleep.
Doggett smiles, he’s well-prepared to deal
with that tomorrow. He turns off the light in the room and rolls onto
his back. He’s surprised to feel Scully curl up next to him, her arm
resting across his body. He wasn’t expecting this kind of contact.
He runs his hand over her arm, and kisses her on the top of her head.
Good night, Dana…
Scully moans a tired response and is well
on her way to sleep, feeling safe and protected in his arms.
INT. BRAD FOLLMER’S OFFICE – 7:22 A.M.
JUNE 1, 2005
Brad places his laptop computer on his desk,
sets down his coffee and sits down in his chair. He turns on his laptop,
preparing for the day ahead of him. Doggett and Mulder should be in
his office to report to duty within the hour.
The intercom on his desk buzzes and Kim Cook’s
voice filters through:
Sir, Agent Mulder is here to see you.
Let him in.
Brad wonders why only Agent Mulder is here.
Agent Doggett should be with him. Brad leans back in his chair. Perhaps
Doggett isn’t in yet...
Mulder comes through the door, the look on his
face tells Brad immediately that something is wrong. Mulder comes
to stand front and center in front of Brad’s desk.
Sir, I have some bad news.
Have a seat.
Brad signals to the chair behind Mulder. Mulder
What is it?
It’s Agent Doggett, sir... (beat)
He’s still in New Orleans.
Brad lets this register.
Why is he still in New Orleans?
Because he wants to continue
working on the case we were on.
(beat) I tried to tell him that
he shouldn’t disobey his direct
superior, but he wouldn’t listen.
He put me on the plane and went back
to the hotel to wait for Agents
Scully and Reyes. (beat) I tried to
talk reason to him, but he wouldn’t
hear it, sir. (beat) He believes that
you think he isn’t capable of working
on this case because of personal feelings.
(beat) I’m sorry, sir.
There’s nothing for you to be
sorry for, Agent Mulder. (beat)
Thank you for reporting this to me.
Yes, sir. (beat) It was my duty
as a federal agent.
Brad nods his head.
I don’t want you to worry about
Agent Doggett. I will take care
of the situation he has created.
(beat) Meanwhile, I believe you are
capable of dealing with Barker on
your own. All right? I’ll join you
later when you interrogate him.
Mulder takes a small gulp, and musters up all
of his being of confidence. He’s hasn’t worked a case all by himself
in such a long time.
Keep me informed. You’re dismissed.
Mulder nods his head at Brad, gets up and exits
Brad let’s out a sigh. Only John Doggett would
think of disobeying his direct superior to work on the Luke Doggett
case. Brad picks up the phone and dials Doggett’s cell phone. He waits
patiently as he waits for Doggett to pick up.
(calm, playing it cool)
Agent Doggett, this is Assistant
Director Brad Follmer.
I hear you’re still in New Orleans.
Yes, I am.
I believe you are supposed to
be up here in D.C. right now.
Isn’t that correct?
There is a small beat of hesitation from John
on the other end.
I sent Agent Mulder up, sir.
Yes, I know. I just spoke with
him. (beat) Did I or did I not
reassign you and Agent Mulder both
to the Michael Barker case, and did
I or did I not remove you from working
on your son’s case?
Yes, sir, you did.
So you’re disobeying me?
I can handle this case, Brad.
I’m not letting personal feelings
jeopardize how I investigate this
case. (beat) I’m capable of-
-Agent Doggett, I have ordered
you to be in D.C. working on the
Barker case. I did not, nor will I
ever order you to work on any personal
case as long as you are in the Bureau
and as long as I am your direct superior.
(beat) If you are not up in D.C. by-
-I’m on this case and-
(talking above him)
-If you are not up in D.C.
this afternoon I will suspend-
-You won’t do that, Brad. (beat)
I’m on this case.
You will be suspended if you
are not in my office by three
o’clock this afternoon. Do you
understand me, Agent Doggett?
The line Doggett is on goes dead. He hung up
on Brad. He’s not going to hear this. Brad won’t suspend him. He’s
Brad lets out a sigh and hangs up the phone.
Doggett must believe he won’t be punished for disobeying his direct
superior because they are friends. We’ll just have to see about that...
INT. HOTEL RESTAURANT – NEW ORLEANS – 6:30 A.M.
Scully and Monica are sitting at a table, with
their fresh pancakes set in front of them and orange juice to drink.
These are my favorite blueberry
pancakes, you’ll love them.
Strawberry is good too.
Yeah. So is-
She stops when she sees Doggett enter the restaurant.
Scully doesn’t notice since her back is to the entrance.
So are what, Monica?
Oh no... John.
Scully turns to follow Monica’s look, and see
John Doggett with an angry look on his face, making his way over to
their table. He sits down with attitude next to Scully.
I’m fine. (beat) What’s to eat?
Johnny Jay Doggett.
Doggett looks up at her with the Glare of Death.
-Yeah, he said that I was
allowed on this case.
No he didn’t. You just
spoke to him. (beat) He’s
going to suspend you, John.
No he won’t. I’m his friend.
John, he’s not Skinner. He’s Brad Follmer.
He’ll do it.
No he won’t. I’m on this case.
What? You think we’re not
capable of working this case
on our own? Do you not trust us?
Doggett says nothing as he snatches a menu from
across the table. He gives her a look.
Well you didn’t find him back in ’93,
now did you?
Monica’s expression changes with the comment
he said inside of his head.
Oh, so that is what this is about?
Blueberry muffins sound good.
Do not change the subject, John.
(beat) Agent Scully and I are very-
-Are you capable of
getting this case done?
He glares at her. New York has been brought
up indirectly between them, and here they go again...
Scully is very bothered by their arguing. It
makes her uneasy and nervous.
(snaps at them)
Agents... How about we drop this
negativity. We’ll just have to work
with John being here, okay? (beat/calmer)
Please don’t fight, I don’t like it.
Doggett and Monica glare at one another for
a moment then fall back into their “normal mode”... but the tension
is still there.
I’m sorry, too.
They eat in silence for the rest of the morning
until they have to go question Robert Harvey.
INT. MULDER / KRYCEK’S OFFICE – 7:53 A.M.
Krycek is sitting behind his desk, holding a
porno magazine in front of his face. Every now and then he lifts his
eyes from the pages and glances around the room, and to the hallway
to make sure that no one is catching what he’s doing.
He looks back down at the publication he holds
in his hand.
POV – KRYCEK
Dr. Seusse’s “Green Eggs and Ham”. He chuckles.
I do not like green eggs and ham.
I will not try them in a box with
He looks back down at “Green Eggs and Ham” and
flips the page.
Krycek doesn’t notice, but Mulder enters the
office, and stops in his tracks when he sees that Krycek is holding
a porno magazine up in front of his face. Mulder rolls his eyes at
Krycek. He is not amused by his partner’s actions.
Krycek yelps, terrified that he’s been caught
reading a kid’s book. The porno magazine and “Green Eggs and Ham”
fly out of his hands and onto the floor. Krycek lets out another loud
yelp when he sees the look Mulder is giving him, he’s actually scared
I’m working on a case on my
own today, can I ask you to
work on reorganizing the files?
I think some of the alphabetizing
is wrong. It would help progress our
workflow if we got that fixed.
No way Jose! I’m reading porn!
Mulder looks down at “Green Eggs and Ham”
that lies on the floor, next to the porn magazine.
You were reading a children’s book.
Krycek squirms in his seat, dammit, he’s
Hey look, I can help you
work on your case.
I don’t need help that you can’t provide.
What’s the case?
Something I’ve worked on before
from many years ago, before you
and I became partners. I worked on
it with Reggie and then later with Scully.
You have nothing to do with it.
Oh yeah, well I’m your partner now.
You’re obligated to tell me.
No, I’m not.
Yes, you are.
Krycek stands up waiting for a “are not”
– “are too” fight to happen. He can’t wait, it’s been forever since
he and Mulder argued like idiots.
Look, just do as you’re told, Krycek.
Mulder goes over to a filing cabinet and
searches for his folder on John Lee Roche. He finds it and takes it
out. He doesn’t say anything to Krycek as he walks out of the office.
Krycek pouts, crossing his arms in front of
him. Why is Mulder still pretending to not be his buddy?! This is
getting out of hand, he’s got to do something about this. Krycek angrily
walks to the office door, going to go trip Mulder in the hallway,
but the Janitor stands in his way.
Out of my way, old man.
Nope. Can’t do that.
Because, you are responsible
for the pain and suffering my
friend Monica went through last year.
So, I think you need to have a
little taste of something called
Sorry, that’s not my favorite
flavor of ice cream. Step aside.
The Janitor shakes his head and wraps his
arm around Krycek’s waist to carry him like a football. He heads to
the men's restroom.
Let me go!
Krycek tries to pound on the Janitor as
he’s being carried to what he believes could be certain death, or
a horrid swirlie.
The Janitor sets Krycek down in a corner on
the floor in the restroom. He turns his back to him and pulls out
a razor, and menacingly turns around to stare down at Krycek. The
Janitor has a sweet smile on his face.
What are you going to do to me?
I hear you pride yourself
on your vanity.
I’m not vain. I’m DA MAN!
Krycek tries to stand up, but the Janitor
pushes on his shoulder to keep him seated on the floor. The Janitor
places the razor blade to one of Krycek’s eyebrows, and he shaves
it completely off. Not both eyebrows, only one.
Ooh… I’m so scared.
So you’re shaving my
You truly are a dumb shit.
The Janitor stands up and offers his hand
to Krycek, to help him to his feet.
You’re not a big bully.
You only think that you are.
You don’t scare me.
The Janitor turns Krycek to see his reflection
in the mirror. Krycek’s eyes pop open, at what he sees. He only has
OH MY GOD YOU MOTHERFUCKER!
This is worse than La Jaconde!
Well, my work here is done.
The Janitor happily walks out of the restroom,
proud of the work he’s done on Krycek’s eyebrow. That should take
several weeks to grow back. Even then, it may never be the same.
Krycek is too worried about his beauty to follow
the Janitor and try to get back at him. He leans in closer to the
mirror to view the destruction done to his face. First the big ol’
scar from the knife fight he had with Monica last year, and now this
missing eyebrow thing, he doesn’t even look like the frickin’ “Mona
Lisa”, she didn’t have any eyebrows. He’s like a two-eyed Cyclops.
(about to cry)
Off of Krycek moping and staring at his
INT. BOB HARVEY’S HOME – 8:16 A.M. NEW ORLEANS,
WEDNESDAY – JUNE 1, 2005
Bob Harvey is leading John, Dana, and Monica
into his living room. The place is clean enough for a low-life like
Bob Harvey. It doesn’t look like it’s been vacuumed or dusted, but
his belongings are put away. It smells like stale cigarettes.
So what’s the FBI need from me now?
Didn’t you two get all you needed back in ’93?
Doggett carefully watches Harvey, wanting
to know the truth about what happened to Luke.
Have you heard of or are you
acquainted with a Michael Barker?
Harvey looks suspiciously from Doggett
Yeah, he’s a friend of mine.
Yeah, some friend. Lies for you,
creating a false alibi when we
first questioned you up in New York.
False alibi? I don’t know what
you’re talking about.
Doggett pulls out a copy of Barker’s written
statement. Harvey looks at it.
Hmm… so now he’s changing his story-
- Do you know what this tells us?
Do you know what this helps explain?
Harvey looks at Doggett, slightly afraid
of the man. Doggett’s eyes are intense with anger and determination.
So Barker’s statement proves that
you weren’t in Salt Lake City. (beat)
You were the man who called in the
location of Luke’s body. Don’t you
find it at all suspicious? You knowing
about the location. You calling that in.
Scully leans forward, her blue eyes meeting
his. She’s just as determined as John to get to the bottom of this
case. Harvey breaks contact with her eyes. John and Monica watch on.
C’mon… either you killed that little
boy, or you know who did… I’ve seen
your file… I know what you like to do
to little boys. (beat) You did a good
job cleaning off Luke’s body… didn’t you?
Very thorough. Autopsy report says there
were signs of sexual abuse, but no semen
or DNA was found.
Scully eyes him, hoping what she’s saying
will get him to speak.
You and I both know that’s the
anomaly… you’ve never washed
nor killed any of your previous victims…
Harvey looks at her, there’s weakness in
In the background, Doggett rolls his eyes, his
jaw is tight and squared off.
Listen here you son-of-a-bitch-
- Agent Doggett.
Scully stands up to face John. She gives
him a look and he stops speaking. Scully waits a beat and looks at
Monica. It’s obvious that John isn’t able to keep his emotions, opinions
and bias in check.
Agent Reyes, could you please
remove Agent Doggett from the room?
Monica nods her head. She’s impressed with
how well Dana is handling the situation. Monica gives John a look,
and leads him out of the house.
Scully takes in a deep breath. She sits back
down in front of Bob Harvey.
I apologize for Agent Doggett’s
outburst. I assure you that will
not happen again.
Harvey is pensive.
Look, ok, I admit I took the
boy, but I swear I didn’t kill him.
What happened, Robert?
Scully takes out a tape recorder and looks
at Harvey for his permission to record what he has to say. He nods
his head and she presses “RECORD”.
I was driving around Long Island, wasting
time before a meeting I had with this mob
guy, Vinny Cordini. I was on this street
and saw the boy… he was… he was riding
his bike. I assumed he was on his way to
Harvey closes his eyes, imagining the scene.
He was a cute kid, and I know I had to
have him, taste his innocence and youth.
I pulled up next to him and asked if he
needed a ride, it was close to eight in
the morning, I figured that maybe he was
running late and would take up my offer.
Parents must not have taught him well or
else he was mad at them, but he accepted
a ride from a stranger.
Harvey smiles at Scully, enjoying talking
You didn’t use any force to get
him to go with you?
No. In fact as I drove with him
he kept talking about how much
he hated his parents, and how
he wasn’t really heading to
school. He decided he was running
away from home. He figured his
parents hated him and maybe they’d
realize that he was important after he was gone.
He didn’t suspect anything
when you didn’t drop him off at school?
Scully is doing her best not to think about
how she’s going to get John to hear this without losing his temper
or delving into another episode of self-blame. It will break him,
possibly destroy him to hear that Luke was running away because he
thought his parents hated him.
I asked him where he wanted to go
down there or something. I told him
I’d take him there, but I had to go
home first to meet with someone. (beat)
The kid liked to play tough, but I could
see tears welling up in his eyes.
Harvey pauses, to let the image of an innocent
little boy sit in her mind.
Anyway, we get to my place and
I tell him to go lie down in my bed…
Scully swallows hard. This hurts her to
hear, but she must keep her cool.
After a minute or two, I couldn’t
stand not touching him, feeling him…
so I crawled in next to him and told
him that I could help him feel better.
Better than his parents ever could…
Harvey takes in a deep breath and slowly
lets it out, a look of satisfaction on his face, not smug, but pure
I had him roll onto his stomach and
I removed his pants. I used a lubricated
condom when I fucked his ass, poor little
thing squirmed and cried out for his mommy
I as I fondled his little prick…
Scully blinks her eyes to keep tears from
Your autopsy didn’t find any DNA
because I practice safe sex.
Why don’t you save all the lurid
details for your written statement.
How did Luke die?
Harvey shakes his head as if it’s a shame
Luke was killed.
Cordini, the guy I was doing business
with, walked in on us. The boy turned
his head and got a good look at his face.
I got off the boy, conducted my business
and Cordini said he had to take care of a problem.
Are you saying that this Cordini killed Luke?
Yeah, he took him and made me go
with him to some motel to wash
the boy up, get rid of anything
I may have left behind. After we
washed him up, Cordini drove
us both out to this field and he
shot the boy, instantly killing
him. Shot him in the back, poor
kid never saw it coming. He only
Scully sees regret in Harvey’s face.
You never intended to kill him, did you?
Harvey shakes his head.
No. I just wanted my way with him.
I was going to take him back
where I picked him up.
Not without scaring him into
not telling anyone, right?
Sounds like you speak from experience-
Just answer the question.
Yeah, I would have done what I
could to get him not to talk.
Ok, so Luke was reported missing…
three days pass. What made you call
in his location?
Saw his parents on TV, pleading for
the boy’s life. I knew if I were in
their position I’d want closure-
- Do you realize by paying Barker
to lie about your location that
you’ve brought years of suffering
to Luke’s parents? An unsolved case
will not bring closure to anyone.
I did what I could. The mob could have
had guys watching me. It was all over
the news when I was brought in for
questioning as the main suspect in his
death. Cordini knew Barker and I were
pals so he struck some kind of deal with
him to say I was in Salt Lake City the
day the boy disappeared. I went with it
because I know the mob has no hesitation
in knocking off anyone – including children -
who poses a threat to them.
Harvey stops. A concerned look is on his
(a bit scared)
In fact, I think I’d like to be taken
into federal protective custody right
now. They could be watching me now. I..
I… I want to cut some deal to help you
find this Cordini and bring him in for that murder.
Are you requesting we get the Federal
Marshalls involved to secure you in
the Federal Witness Protection Program?
Scully’s heart sinks. John is not going
to like this. It would mean that Harvey would start a new life somewhere
else, and not have to pay for any crimes he’s committed, including
the kidnapping and rape/molestation of Luke.
Yes. I’ll cooperate and do what
it takes to bring in Cordini so
long as I’m promised protection.
Chills run through Scully’s body. She nods
You believe your life is in
danger as we speak?
(takes a deep breath)
Sit on the ground and stay below
the view of the windows. I’ll
inform Agents Doggett and Reyes
of your request and we can call in
more agents to get you to the FBI safely.
Harvey nods his head and sits down on the
ground, keeping low. Scully stands.
I’ll be right back.
Scully walks to the front door and outside
to John and Monica. It looks like they’ve had a heated argument.
Doggett sees Scully and approaches her quickly,
What the Hell were you thinking?!
Kicking me out of there?! This is
my son’s case, Agent Scully, I deserve…
no, I have a right to be involved in
the questioning of this suspect!
Scully gives him a look, this quiets him.
An uneasy calm washes over him. He can tell by the look on her face
that something big has just happened.
Bob Harvey has confessed to kidnapping
Luke. He’s also given the name of the man
who killed him. He’s asking for protective
custody, and is willing to help us apprehend
the killer so long as he’s entered into WITSEC.
It feels as if time has stopped.
John holds his breath to bottle up the anger
that flows through him. If Harvey is entered into the Witness Protection
Program, then he wouldn’t be punished for taking his son, and hurting
him. He’d be a free man, living a new life.
Doggett shakes his head and takes a step towards
Scully. She takes a step back away from him. She’s on edge due to
his outburst and yelling when she came outside.
No. We can’t do that.
John… Luke was killed by a man involved
with the mob. Bob Harvey has risked his
life by confessing today. He’s ready to
cooperate to help us bring down Luke’s
murderer, a man named Vinny Cordini.
I don’t think we have any other option.
Doggett shakes his head, this is bullshit.
No. If he took my son, he has to…
Doggett bites his lower lip. Tears have
welled up in his eyes. He’s beginning to break. Scully looks to Monica.
Mon’, could you call in some
reinforcements so we can
safely bring Harvey in?
I’m on it.
Monica pulls out her cell phone and dials
the New Orleans field office. She walks away from them.
Scully carefully approaches Doggett, afraid
of where his emotions may be.
He raises his eyes to look at her. He is
angry, his eyes are narrowed. Scully’s face twists with worry.
You’re not angry with me, are you?
Jesus Christ, Dana! I’ve talked to
you about Luke! You know how for the
past twelve years I’ve blamed myself
for his death, for not giving him a
ride to school, and now that we got
this asshole, you’re standing here, in
my face, telling me you’re behind the
idea of protecting him?!
He angrily throws his hands up in the air
and turns his back to her.
Scully doesn’t know what to say. John’s never
been this angry with her. In fact, this may just be the first time
he’s ever yelled at her and meant it.
John… this is exactly why A.D. Follmer
didn’t want you on this case. Your
judgment is biased-
(quickly turns to face her)
- And you’re sympathizing with a
child molester, a murderer!
He didn’t kill your son. This man,
Cordini, did. Harvey has remorse
that it happened, that’s why he
called in the tip that led the
investigative team to Luke’s location-
- That’s bullshit and you know it!
Doggett storms away from her and into Harvey’s
house. Scully’s eyes go wide. What is he doing? Whatever it is, it
can’t be good.
Scully quickly follows John inside just
as she enters, John throws a hard punch in Harvey’s face.
Doggett ignores her. He glares down at
Why are you lyin’ to us? Why are
you pointing a finger at another
man when you know that you killed my son?!
Agent Doggett, step away from him
right now. You don’t want to
compromise this case anymore than
you already have.
Doggett glances back at her. He knows he’s
done wrong. He knows Dana and Monica are better suited to handle this
case because they aren’t as strongly connected to its outcome as he
is. He’s stepped way over the line. He knows that he’s going to have
to face some kind of discipline for this.
I’m going to have to report that
you assaulted a man who as of a few
minutes ago is under federal protective custody.
Doggett tightens his jaw. He doesn’t argue.
Scully kneels down by Harvey. She grabs a Kleenex
box and offers Harvey a tissue.
Hold this to your nose and
tilt your head back, it’ll stop the bleeding.
Harvey takes the Kleenex and does as he’s
told. Scully stands up and gives Doggett a look – she doesn’t want
to deal with him right now.
EXT. CENTRAL PARK – 12:30 P.M.
NEW YORK CITY, NEW YORK
Marita Covarrubias is sitting alone in a nice
grassy area of Central Park. She’s holding a six inch sub sandwich
in her hand and is enjoying her lunch hour.
The sun is shining and it’s a beautiful afternoon.
Marita takes another bite into her sandwich.
Marita! Stop eating and help me!
Marita swallows and looks up, Krycek is
walking toward her. He has one hand covering one of his eyebrows,
the side the Janitor shaved off.
Alex! What are you doing here?
Marita stands up to greet him – a confused
look on her face. Why is Alex covering his eyebrow?
Everyone is being mean to me.
You came all the way up to
New York in time for my lunch
break to complain? (beat)
Did you hurt yourself?
She tries to move his hand.
Don’t. You’ll be terrified.
Marita moves his hand and sees that there
is no eyebrow. She quickly covers her mouth to keep from laughing
Laugh it up, Blondie.
Krycek plops down on the ground, grumpy.
What’d you do?
She sits next to him. She’s humored by
this, but at the same time she feels sorry for him.
That damn janitor… he forced
me into the bathroom and held
me down as he shaved off my eyebrow.
What did you do to him?
Nothing. He said it was because
of what happened to Monica at
the Facility! That was so not
my fault. I’m a victim of that too.
I was played like a pawn in checkers.
Marita bites her lower lip to not laugh
– he means chess.
My poor little Sasha…
She leans over and kisses him on the cheek
and runs her hand through his hair.
And then, actually before that, Mulder,
refused to let me help him on a case he’s
working on. It’s been one month, thirty-one days,
and twelve minutes since he broke up with me on
April Fools Day, and ok, he sounded serious
about it, but I just kept on hoping it was
an April Fools Day joke.
Don’t worry about it. I’m sure
everything will work itself out in the end.
But Fox is my best friend. (sniffles)
I mean if you didn’t exist and Dana
refused me, and he never met Diana, he
and I would be soul mates, friends forever
and dare I say… lovers.
I think you’re going overboard here.
All right, yeah, maybe not lovers, but
everything else I meant. (beat) We even
have a song together.
Are you sure you’re in love with me?
Yes, my sweet Snuffles. How could
you ever doubt my love?
Snuggums, you not just ten seconds
ago said you and Mulder could be lovers.
Krycek is quiet. Oops. He lowers his head.
I’m sorry. You know you mean the world,
no, the universe to me. (beat) I have
plans for our future together you know.
He looks up at her with his loving emerald
Well, we’ll get married in England
after somehow humans beat the aliens
when they come to colonize the planet.
You’ll wear a beautiful white dress since
Daddy C thinks you’re still a virgin.
We’ll buy a two-story house in a nice
suburban neighborhood in Alexandria.
After a couple years, you’ll come home
from work and I’ll already be home, cooking
dinner, Borsch, and you’ll tell me you’re pregnant.
What are our kids’ names?
Jimmy, Joey, and Tommy, Alice and
Stephanie. (beat) Jimmy and Joey
will be twins. They’ll have my luscious
green eyes and your sun-kissed blond
hair. (beat) Stephanie will be the
youngest by nine years. She will be a
whoopsie, you know we forget to use
protection, but we won’t tell her that,
and we’ll love her just the same.
Krycek takes hold of her hand and kisses
Now, Snuffles, don’t be sad, but
I’ll die first. Which is proper since
then I can protect you from beyond.
I’ll be almighty and powerful.
(cocks eyebrow, smiles)
You’re not going to turn into
the Devil again, are you?
Krycek’s eyes brighten with pure joy.
Marita! Don’t you see?! We’re
already married! Remember we
were wed in the Afterlife!
Until death do us part!
Actually, it was until life do us part.
Death. Marriage is marriage. You
are my wife, doesn’t matter if
it happened on the other side!
Krycek stands up, excited.
Where are you going?
He tugs on her arms and helps her to her
feet. He sweeps her up into his arms and carries her. Marita giggles.
I’m going to buy you – us – wedding rings!
Marita smiles. This may actually be more
fun than being traditional – what the heck they can be married if
not by law, but in their hearts. That’s where it matters the most
Does this mean I don’t have
to go back to the U.N. today?
Yes! Spend the day with me!
We’ll get a hotel room, the
honeymoon suite, and make love all day.
Marita kisses Krycek on his bare eyebrow,
lipstick is now on it. He continues carrying her out of Central Park.
After a few beats his pace slows down and his back begins to hunch.
Would it be easier if you put
me down and we walked holding hands?
No. I can do this.
He struggles some more. It looks like someone
needs to make a few more visits to the gym.
Ok, maybe you’re right.
He sets her down and pauses to catch his
breath. Marita grins at him. He looks cute wearing her lipstick on
his bare eyebrow.
You know… you don’t have to live
with Spender anymore now that we’re married.
Snuffles… we may be married, but
we’ve only just renewed our relationship
in the past few months… I think, right?
Well, we’ve been on and off again
so often I’ve lost track of when we
officially got back this time around.
Anyway, my point is that I still
want you to have your independence
like Doctor Peterson said you should
have to cope with having been outside
your own control for so long.
He takes hold of her hand. Marita looks
Yeah, I guess you’re right… do you
promise not to hit on other women
from now on?
Marita, I wouldn’t be the Hunky Punk
if I couldn’t be a flirt. I will promise
you this though… my body is for you and
only you. I promise from now until the end
of my life that I will only have sex, fuck,
bang, have intercourse, copulate, go to
bed with, breed, fool around with, fornicate,
go all the way with, have sexual relations
with, make out, lay, mate, procreate, screw,
be intimate and make love to you. But if I do
die first, you have my permission to be with
another man, though I can’t promise I won’t haunt him.
You’re so silly. But please try to
control the Hunky Punk and not flirt
too much. It hurts my feelings. But
I guess since you promised never to
have sex with anyone else I have
nothing to worry about.
Exactly. Now what kind of rings
do we want to get?
And so the happily newly married couple
walk on to find the rings to forever unite them in marriage.
INT. INTERROGATION ROOM – FBI HEADQUARTERS –
Mulder and Michael Barker are sitting at a table
in the middle of the room. Mulder has been talking with Barker since
9 o’clock this morning and has gotten nowhere.
That’s nine hours of listening to Barker talk
about his life starting with the day he was born. Listening to him
talk about his childhood, and how horrible it was growing up in his
family, his years in high school when he realized that he was attracted
to young boys and not girls his age, the time he did in prison, what
he thinks of his parole officer, his opinions on the President and
the current situation overseas in Iraq, Martha Stewart’s time behind
bars, his favorite television shows, music he hates, and how he thinks
Agent Scully must have been a pretty little girl, exactly what he’d
look for when selecting his victims… how he wishes she were a young
Mulder sighs. He’s had enough of this guy being
up on a soapbox.
Michael. As interesting as it’s
been hearing all about your life
and opinions, I’m really here for
one reason: to have you tell me what
you know about Roche’s last victim.
We’ve already figured out the pictures
Agent Scully found in your truck are
crimes committed prior to your previous conviction.
Barker watches Mulder carefully.
Listen, you’ve confessed to withholding
information on the kidnapping and murder
of a police officer’s child. You violated
the terms of your parole. You’re looking at
18 to 20 years in prison already. You have
nothing to lose. (beat) You tell me the truth
about Roche’s last heart, and I can suggest
to the judge a reduced sentence, less
time in the big house.
Barker sighs and pushes back in his chair.
Roche said if the feds ever came
after me for what he told me that
I was supposed to drop the name
Samantha Mulder when asked about the last heart.
Are you saying my sister,
Samantha, is his last victim?
Mulder’s face is tense. He doesn’t believe
him. Sam was used to manipulate him in this case before. He won’t
let that happen this time around.
No. What I’m saying is that John
wanted me to say that.
Mulder stands up, frustrated. He rolls
up his sleeves.
We’ve been in here nine hours and
you haven’t given me anything.
Now do you or do you not know who
the last heart belongs to?
Mulder places his hand on the table and
stares down at Barker.
Caitlin Elizabeth Morgan.
Mulder nods his head. Caitlin. Was it a
coincidence or a plan that Roche had kidnapped a little girl named
Caitlin back in 1996?
Mulder looks back at the two-way mirror. Brad
has been in the observation room this whole time too.
Caitlin Elizabeth Morgan? (beat)
A guard will be in to take you
back to holding while I check up
on this. Is there anything else
you know about Caitlin?
Roche only gave me a name… oh, and
he also said something about Woonsocket,
Rhode Island… I hear it’s quite wooded up there.
Mulder nods his head and leaves the room.
He meets Brad out in the hallway.
Sorry that took so long, sir.
It’s all right. We both know low-lifes
like this like to get up on their
soapbox. You kept trying the entire
time, and what’s important is that you
got a name that we can cross reference
with the missing persons database, plus
a location where we can start a search.
I’ll call up to the field office
in Boston, and alert them to this
case. See if they have the manpower
to lend to begin searching parks in
Woonsocket, especially if any parks
have names related to “Alice In Wonderland”.
If not there, then anywhere in Rhode Island
or Massachusetts. It’s part of Roche’s
signature – always something to do with
the children’s book.
I’ve got a few things to finish
up here before I head home. Keep
me updated on your progress.
Mulder gives him two thumbs up and heads
down the hallway.
And Agent Mulder, you’re doing a good job.
Mulder glances back at him with a grin
on his face. It feels so good to actually be working cases rather
than sitting around downstairs in the basement office not doing a
Brad heads to the elevator to head up to his
office on the fourth floor. The elevator doors close and he lets out
a heavy sigh. While he was in the Observation Room, he received a
call from Monica. She told him that she, Dana, and John would be back
in D.C. by 4 o’clock this afternoon. That was two hours ago. She informed
him that Harvey had requested federal protection for his cooperation,
and that John had punched Harvey.
Brad’s sure he’ll have to deal with Doggett
before the day is done.
After the call, Brad called up to the New York
field office and spoke with ADIC Thompson, giving him the name Vinny
Cordini, and why he needed to be brought in. He must not have been
hard to find since only six hours after he called Thompson, Thompson
called back to let him know Cordini is in their custody.
Brad called Monica and instructed her to go
up to New York to work with Thompson’s agents on the case. He requested
that John and Dana return to D.C. John because of his assault on Harvey.
Dana because he honestly does not want her on this case after he saw
her reactions to Barker yesterday. His gut tells him that she’s sensitive
to working sex crime cases, especially when it involves pedophiles.
The elevator doors open and Brad steps out and
heads to his office. Kim Cook is still at her desk outside his office
You’re still here?
Just helping you stay on top of
things, plus it’s not like I have
anyone to go home to. (beat) Agent
Reyes just called to let you know
that Harvey has been entered into
Sure can be quick when they need
to be, huh? (beat) Why don’t you
go home, it’s been a long day.
Thank you, sir.
You try to have a nice night, sir.
You too, and thank you for
your hard work today.
Kim grabs her purse and leaves.
Brad enters his office. In less than an hour
he’ll have been here for twelve hours. He sits down at his desk and
sees that Kim has organized the files he had left behind earlier in
There’s a knock on his door. He looks up and
sees John Doggett in the doorway, he looks defeated.
Assistant Director, may I speak
with you for a moment?
Brad looks at him, this is not what he expected.
Come in, Agent Doggett.
Doggett approaches the desk. He does not take
a seat. Instead, he takes out his FBI badge and weapon and lies them
down in front of Brad, on the desk.
Agent Reyes informed me that she spoke
to you about my actions this morning.
I just wanted to say first that I know
what I did was unprofessional and inappropriate,
and that I deserve whatever suspension
you hand me. Hell, I probably deserve a four-bagger.
You’ll get a letter of censure
and a two week suspension.
Doggett nods his head. He’s a better agent than
what he showed earlier in the day.
Thank you for coming in here and
doing the right thing.
I had a talk with Agent Scully.
She uh… made me see reason.
She’s good at handling situations like that.
Brad senses that Doggett wants to stick
around for some reason. He checks his wristwatch: 6:37 P.M.
It’s nearly twenty till seven.
Why don’t I walk you out of here
and we both head home?
That beats having a security escort.
Brad and John head out of the office. Brad
locks his office door behind him.
Can we talk off the record?
We’re officially off the clock.
I want the FBI to do whatever
it can to prevent Bob Harvey
from being entered into WITSEC.
He may not have killed Luke, but
he took him and molested him.
A man like that needs to be brought down.
Monica left a message not too
long ago to let me know Harvey
has been entered into WITSEC.
I’m sure the U.S. Marshalls got
him set up as soon as Cordini was
in custody and questioned about
his involvement in Luke’s death.
Doggett takes a deep breath. This news
infuriates him, but there’s nothing he can do about it now. Even if
he went to the U.S. Marshalls to find out where they placed Harvey,
they can’t disclose that information.
Just remember that this Harvey
led us to Luke’s killer. We can
bring that man to justice now.
What’s done is done, right?
There’s not much we can do now.
I guess I should call Barbara
and let her know this has happened.
They get to the elevator and head to the
parking garage. They are quiet the entire time they are in the elevator.
The doors open and they are in the parking garage.
They walk, heading to their cars.
How’s Dana doing? She was quite
shaken yesterday when she spoke with Barker.
She’s quite the professional.
Though last night she mentioned
not wanting to be alone… that
she needed me there with her.
Doggett rubs the back of his neck.
There’s something else?
Not really, only that I had
hoped she was going to finally
open up to me. I mean I know
that she’s been through some
pretty bad stuff, but she won’t
talk about it with me. I wish
she would, it would only help.
You’re good for each other, John.
Remember these things can take
time. Mon’ and I are dealing
with problems too. You’ve got to
stick with it, be there for her.
I’m doing the best I can.
Doggett gets to his truck.
I’ll see you around.
Take care of yourself.
Doggett gets into his truck and starts
the engine and drives off.
TIME CUT TO:
EXT. MORGAN FAMILY HOME – 3:00 P.M.
WOONSOCKET, RHODE ISLAND
TUESDAY – JUNE 7, 2005
Mulder pulls up in front of the Morgan’s home
in his gray Bucar. It’s been three days since the body of Caitlin
Elizabeth Morgan was found in an isolated area not too far from Cheshire,
MA. The lab techs were able to positively identify the skeleton of
the young girl after the Morgan family was contacted and asked to
provide the FBI with any DNA they may still have from their daughter
after all these years. It didn’t take long for the lab to confirm
a match once the sample arrived at the lab.
Mulder sighs, it’s been a long past six days
that he’s been up working with agents from the Boston field office,
and now, finally, he can tell the Morgan’s that they found their daughter,
which will bring the family some closure.
Mulder gets out of the car and walks up to the
front door of the house and knocks three times.
After a few seconds an older woman (late 50s)
answers the door, this is Caitlin’s mother, Carol.
Agent Mulder, so good to
see you again.
May I come in?
Of course. Would you like
something to drink? Water? Juice?
Carol leads Mulder into the living room.
He looks around, there are still framed photos of Carol, her husband,
and Caitlin sitting on the top of end tables and hanging on the wall.
She was a cute little girl, dirty blond hair, blue eyes, pudgy cheeks
and a smile to melt even the coldest of hearts.
I’m ok, but thank you anyway.
I assume you’re here to tell
me how the DNA verification went.
Carol sits down on the couch and Mulder
sits across from her in an armchair.
The results came back a match.
Carol’s eyes well up with tears, and she
places her hand over her mouth.
(soft, more to herself)
My sweet baby girl… (to Mulder)
Can you tell me what happened, or
do you not know?
Mulder looks at her with sad eyes. This
is always the hardest part of cases like this, informing the family.
Her remains were found in a wooded
area up near Cheshire, Massachusetts.
Mulder pauses to rethink his approach.
The man who hurt her is dead.
He has been for nine years now.
Before he was killed, he was locked
away for similar crimes. He spent
six years in prison before his death.
Carol wipes a tear from her eye and gives
Mulder a soft smile.
It feels like such a relief, you
know? Finally knowing what happened.
Mulder nods his head, he can imagine what
a relief it must be to find out what really happened to a missing
loved one, even if in the end, it turns out they are dead.
For a moment he thinks of Samantha.
These past thirty-one years I’ve
imagined that Caitlin may be alive,
living with the person who took her.
If her little body was spared years
of suffering because her kidnapper
killed her… I’m glad it ended this way.
I know that sounds horrible of me, but
it’s the truth.
It’s not horrible to feel that way, it’s normal.
Carol nods her head, glad to hear that
what she’s feeling is normal.
Well, I shouldn’t be taking up any
more of your time. I’ve got some
family to call now, and you’ve got
to get back out there and do your
best to stop more monsters.
Carol stands up as does Mulder. They walk
to the front door. Carol extends her hand to shake his.
Thank you so much… for everything.
Mulder shakes her hand.
You’re welcome. (beat) If you need
anything else having to do with
your daughter, don’t hesitate to call
me, or the field office in Boston.
Mulder steps out of the house.
Take care, ma’am.
You know I will.
Carol shuts the door and Mulder lets out
a heavy sigh. A sigh of relief. Finally, after all these years, all
the families of Roche’s victims have closure. He puts his hands in
his pants pockets and strolls back to his car, a small grin on his
Once in the car, he retrieves his keys and is
about to start the engine. However, pain stings his heart. He’s thinking
of Samantha. About how it seems he’ll never find out what happened
to her. Is she dead? Is she alive? Does she remember him if she is
alive? What would she look like today? Would he recognize her if he
walked by her on the street?
He pulls out his wallet from his pocket and
opens it up. He flips through the pictures until he gets to one of
him and Samantha when they were kids. It’s an old, worn photograph.
Mulder’s favorite. He stares at it for a long time. He chokes back
tears and bites his lower lip to keep from crying. How is it that
he’s been with the FBI for so long and still has no leads on his own
sister’s disappearance? Why must he continue to suffer without closure
all these years? Mulder closes his wallet and sets it on the passenger
He turns the key to start the engine, and he
rests his hands on the steering wheel to help him regain his composure.
After a minute, he picks up his cell phone and
dials Scully. A few seconds later she picks up.
Scully. It’s over.
Oh God… Mulder… I hate to say
this, but now really isn’t a good time.
Mulder hears worry in her voice.
What’s going on?
INT. BRAD FOLLMER’S OFFICE – CONTINUOUS
Scully is standing in the corner of the room,
her back to Brad and John who are at Brad’s desk. The tension is thick
and it’s eerily quiet.
(quiet, into phone)
Remember last time we talked I told
you we found the guy who killed John’s son?
A.D. Follmer got a call an hour
ago from where Cordini is being
held. He’s confessed that he lied
and that he didn’t kill Luke.
Mulder is quiet on the other end of the
What about that guy who we
put into Witness Protection?
Brad pulled some strings with the
U.S. Marshalls and got them to give
us the location where they placed Harvey.
Field agents in Missouri are working with
the U.S. Marshalls to bring him back in.
We’re waiting to hear back from them now.
Scully sniffles back a cry and quickly
wipes a tear from her face. Mulder hears this.
Mulder, I’m fine. (beat) It’s just
hard watching John this past week,
seeing all the emotions he’s going
through. I mean not even a week ago
he thought his son’s killer was found
and now this…
Brad’s office phone rings. Scully looks
back at John and Brad. John’s eyes are sad, tired, worried. His expression
asks for her to come be with him.
Mulder, I’ve got to go.
We can talk later, ok?
I’ll be back soon.
Scully turns off her phone and goes to
sit down next to John while Brad speaks on the phone. By the look
on Brad’s face, Scully and Doggett can tell something is terribly
wrong. Scully takes hold of Doggett’s hand.
Brad hangs up the phone and lets out a heavy
sigh. This can’t be good.
They got to Harvey’s new address
and he wasn’t there. The place
looked as if he up and left in a hurry.
Doggett squeezes Scully’s hand unknowingly.
She can feel the anger inside him.
What does that mean?
He knows what it means, he just can’t believe
this has happened.
It means we were being played.
My guess is that somebody in
New Orleans is dirty, heard
Headquarters was sending agents
down to question Harvey. So plans
were made for him to hand over a
decoy so he could use us for protection.
Then he got his protection and quickly
disappeared so we couldn’t find him.
So what? That’s it? There’s nothing
more we can do?
Doggett quickly glances at Scully, hoping
that maybe she can provide a miracle solution.
So both the man who took my little
boy, and the identity of the man
who killed him are out of our reach?
Doggett angrily stands up, letting go of
Scully’s hand. He runs his hand through his hair. Scully looks up
at him, she’s concerned and worried for him.
Brad and Scully can tell that John is trying
to think of something to say to show them exactly what he’s feeling,
but no words come out of his mouth. Instead, he sits down on the couch
in the back of Brad’s office, and covers his face with his hands and
Scully and Brad exchange glances, they don’t
know what to say to make things better. Scully stands up and goes
to him. She sits down next to him, and gently rubs his back. Brad
follows, but remains standing.
John, I know there’s nothing I can
say to make things better, but remember
that Harvey is a criminal of habit.
Chances are that one day he’ll hurt
another child, and get caught. And when
that happens, the FBI will be all over him.
He will pay for what he’s done – no more
deals. We’ll do everything we can when that
day comes to find out the name of the man
who killed Luke, and you will have closure.
Doggett looks up at Brad.
And how long will that take? It’s
already been twelve years… what
do I tell Barbara? That I fucked
up again and now the man that took
Luke is out there, living life as
a free man?
I’ll call Barbara.
Doggett shakes his head and looks at the
ground. He can’t believe this has happened.
The room falls silent for several beats. Doggett
So now what?
He looks Scully in the eye and sees that
she’s hurting for him, this breaks her heart as much as it does his.
No answer is provided to his question, and off
the hopeless silence of the room.